Anti-“Vaccers” Versus Reality

This story didn’t happen in the United States, but it easily could have. In Auckland, New Zealand, a couple of parents made the decision to pay heed to all of the conspiracy theories regarding the dangers of vaccinations, and how their children would be better off without them. No word on whether they are avid readers of this nutjob and her collected works.

Well wouldn’t you know it, their kid got tetanus.  He was rushed to the hospital and ended up on life support in an induced coma.  He’s out now, but the recovery is going to be a long and painful process.  Among other things, he has to learn how to eat and walk again, and still suffers from spasms as a result of the infection.  Now here’s the upside:

“Son’s ordeal was our fault”, say parents

[After their son Alijah fell ill, t]hey immediately immunised their other children and wrote to Alijah’s school to warn parents who had not vaccinated against the disease and others such as whooping cough.

“It was me that put my son in this situation,” Mr Williams said.

Thanks Mom and Dad. Remember, I choose your nursing home.

“Parents like us make the decision to not vaccinate on very little factual information about the actual consequences of the diseases – massive pain, disability and death – and a lot of non-factual, emotive information from the Internet stating inflated figures on the frequency and severity of adverse reactions and conspiracy theories about ‘evil’ doctors, governments and drug companies.”

In this particular case it had nothing to do with religion but just the belief that all of the frightening horror stories about the deadly side effects of vaccinations were true.  I’d actually prefer to deal with people like this over the ones who are well aware of their benefit, but choose not to vaccinate anyway because God told them not to.  As with the Williams family, their eyes were opened when their son became a data point.

Auckland Regional Public Health clinical director Dr Julia Peters said parents who did not immunise their children were making choices with potentially far-reaching implications for society.

They should think about whether they might infect someone without the same level of defence as them, for example, someone with cancer or a baby who was not yet immunised.  So I think when people (think) ‘it’s just about me and my individual choice’, actually that’s not true.”

The decision whether or not to vaccinate should not be left to the parent.  Sorry.  Not when there is so much at stake from a public health perspective, and especially not when the parents decline based on fear and misinformation.  If there is a valid medical reason a child cannot get immunized, then by all means they’re exempt and some other way should be found to protect them and those with whom they’re in contact. Vaccines are obviously not perfect and there are some potential side effects, but the good they do significantly outweighs the harm making them a necessity in any industrialized society.

There are some who would crow about freedom and personal liberty when something like this is proposed, but to them I say “tough shit”.  Their rights end when mine begin.  If an increasing number of people choose not to immunize their kids, then we’re all susceptible to these diseases, even if we were vaccinated ourselves … and I’m in no mood to suffer for their ignorance, regardless of its origins.

I’m glad, at least, that Alijah is making a recovery and that the parents have seen the light.  Maybe testimony from former “believers” will end up carrying more weight than the collective voice of the medical community.  That’s a sad statement to make, but I guess if that’s what it takes to get more people on board, I’ll take it for now.

This entry was posted in Dr. Bob's House of Crap, generic skepticism and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to Anti-“Vaccers” Versus Reality

  1. Barneysday says:

    Excellent post. So many have forgotten or never knew the pain and disruption that formerly fatal diseases wrought on families and communities. The generations who have survived in good health because of the immunizations are countless, they’ve also allowed a complacency and lowered our guard. Lowered just enough that ignorant parents and TV Personalities have been allowed to weigh their influence way beyond medical fact to levels that are almost voodooism.

    Thanks for a great post

    • I sometimes wonder how people can think like this, but then I’m reminded of the instructions we get for taking antibiotics: take the entire course – even after you feel better. A lot of people still don’t – even though they were sick only a few days before – and end up getting sicker as a result. If they do that in response to an illness spanning several days, it’s no wonder they can’t wrap their heads around the need to prevent diseases we’ve only read about in history books.

      Thanks for reading!

      • Barneysday says:

        In this country, we have also given way too much credibility to second rate “stars” like Jenny McCarthy and her stupid fight against immunization. They stand in front of a camera and act for a living, how does that possibly cross over into health care expertise?

        • It doesn’t have to. The average American citizen is so lacking in even the most basic scientific literacy that it requires very little “contrary evidence” to lead them to believe they’ve been lied to by the scientific community. Remember – it takes only an accusation to make some people assume guilt. The same goes with this vaccination nonsense. Put a pretty face on a conspiracy theory, repeat it enough times, and *POOF* … you have an argument that many consider to be just as valid as almost a century of medical data and consensus.

  2. hughcurtler says:

    Good blog! It’s a sign of the times: knee-jerk reactions from misinformation.

  3. Verrain says:

    Well said, my friend. Just a minor nitpick though, tetanus is caused by a bacteria not a virus.

  4. Pingback: Vaccinate. Just Do It. You Won’t Get Autism … | Crimes Against Divinity

  5. Pingback: Not Good Enough. | Crimes Against Divinity

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s