Wait, God Did This on Purpose??

Eric and Ruth Brown Accept Daughter Pearl Joy’s Illness Holoprosencephaly As ‘God’s Will’

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (RNS) Eric and Ruth Brown believe nothing about daughter Pearl Joy’s life is a mistake.

They say God gave Pearl her bright red hair and wide blue eyes, as well as the genetic disorder that created a cleft in her upper lip and caused her brain’s development to stall in the first weeks in the womb.

“Things didn’t go wrong,” Eric Brown said. “God has designed Pearl the way he wanted, for his glory and our good.”

I’ll admit right off that I’m not a parent, nor do I ever plan on being one, so there’s no way I’ll be able to fully understand or appreciate the kind of turmoil these people are going through with the birth of their daughter and her condition.  But let’s get a brief description of this particular disorder:

Holoprosencephaly is a disorder caused by the failure of the prosencephalon (the embryonic forebrain) to sufficiently divide into the double lobes of the cerebral hemispheres. The result is a single-lobed brain structure and severe skull and facial defects. In most cases of holoprosencephaly, the malformations are so severe that babies die before birth. In less severe cases, babies are born with normal or near-normal brain development and facial deformities that may affect the eyes, nose and upper lip.

This is not a small defect, and there is no cure.  The root of it lies in the brain’s failure to divide into two hemispheres, and the prognosis depends on its severity.  Most babies die before birth.  Some will survive, but with varying degrees of functionality.  In Pearl’s case, the condition is pretty bad:

She’ll likely never walk or read or speak.  Doctors have given her a year. That doesn’t matter to her parents.  […]  She has seizures on a daily basis, has a weakened immune system and has been back to the hospital at least five times in the past three months.

This is really where I’m stuck:  why would you want to bring another living thing into this world to live out a short existence of seizures, illness, and profoundly stunted mental development?  It may be an easy choice for some people to make, since the consideration is only on life and not the quality of it … but it wouldn’t be for me.

Letting go will not be easy. But the Browns say their faith tells them that death is not the end of Pearl’s life.  “When she is done here on Earth, she is not done for good,” Ruth Brown said. “Heaven will be easier for her.”

I have to admit that part of me honestly hopes – however briefly – that there is a heaven, if only for her sake.  It’s an understandable coping mechanism, and it would possibly be something I would find myself thinking if I were them.  Eric and Ruth Brown think to themselves that no matter how much pain and suffering their daughter is going through right now, she will soon be in a place where that pain can’t find her anymore, and she will live for all eternity in the light of her maker.

As a non-believer, however … I find this story both heartbreaking and infuriating.  I consider the idea of bringing a child into this world – knowing full well that she will suffer terribly and be at the mercy of a genetic defect that will kill her within the span of a year – is one of the worst exercises of parental decision making I’ve ever seen.  I can’t see it as anything more than cruel and selfish on her parents’ part to subject this child to a short life of suffering and misery.

And then … to chalk this entire situation up to the will of God and say that he gave her this (relatively common) affliction for “his glory”, I just … no words.  Sorry.  What possible glory can come from preventing someone from forming properly in the womb and ending their life before allowing them to even be consciously aware of it happening?  To say that this was done deliberately on the part of an omniscient, benevolent God as part of some kind of “plan” just makes it all the more nonsensical and pointless.

This entry was posted in Atheism and Personal Life, Freedom from Religion, Religion in the News and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Wait, God Did This on Purpose??

  1. ericbbrown says:

    Hey. I’m Pearl’s father. I tried to comment earlier, but it didn’t go through. Sorry if it ends up posting twice.
    First, thank you for taking time to read her story, and thanks for taking time to write about it. Thank you also, for the gracious tone that you’ve written with. You didn’t have to be gracious, and many others haven’t been.
    You’ve asked some great questions here, and they don’t have easy answers. I certainly don’t think I can throw down an answer card that will adequately and flawlessly answer everything you’ve posted about, but if you’d like, I’d love to talk with you. Let me know if you’re up for a phone call, and feel free to check out more of her story at pearljoybrown.wordpress.com I don’t actually run that site, and the comments are fairly heavily moderated, due to recent media coverage. Obviously, there’s a lot of folks who aren’t a huge fan of my family, but there’s no need to trivialize her story by turning her blog into a messy debate page.
    Thanks again, and I hope you have a great weekend.

    -Eric Brown

    • Hi Eric – sorry for the delay in getting your comment approved. The Day Job takes priority over everything else, and I usually only get around to blog maintenance after it’s done. Drafting posts and comments are usually relegated to the wee hours, making for some occasionally interesting proofreading the following morning when my brain finally manages its way out of first gear.

      I’m honestly quite surprised you found my blog. I’ve sometimes likened myself to an old street preacher who stands on the same obscure corner every day, holding up the same signs, reading the same sermons, oblivious to the constant flow of passers-by … only today I turn around and realize someone’s actually paying attention. Who would have thought?

      As for both the practical and philosophical questions I raised, I don’t expect you to have (or be required to give me) a set of clear or well thought-out answers … nor do I think any of them are easy to come by. The issues I raise and the opinions that I express are from the perspective of a non-believer with no plans for children of his own. I’m able to say what I would do if faced with a situation like yours, but I admit the possibility that could change if confronted with the inevitable emotional attachment that comes with the prospect of dealing with my own child as opposed to someone else’s.

      The reason I wrote about the article was almost exclusively because of the religious element, which clearly provoked a stronger response. You told your story – in part on HP and in more detail in your blog – and how this entire experience has made you feel even closer to God. I see the same story and think to myself that this is a perfect example of why I can’t bring myself to believe in the first place. This is obviously where you and I differ greatly – and we can talk about this in more detail if you like – but I’ll leave that up to you. The last thing you probably need with all of the other things going on in your life right now is some random guy on the Internet throwing rocks at you and your religion for no good reason.

      I appreciate your offer to get in touch by phone, but given my work schedule and a near-obsessive desire for a wall of separation between real life and the Internet, I prefer to keep my correspondences via email. I do this to everyone, so don’t think I’m singling you out in that regard.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s